Knicks · Final Vote: Yay or Nay for JR Smith? (page 3)

CashMoney @ 2/14/2012 4:53 PM
AnubisADL wrote:JR Smith is only 26 yrs old too and at this point he is better than Jamal Crawford. Old Jamal Crawford is worth 5 million a year. So getting Smith for 2.5 million is a steal. Sadly he if we get him it will likely be a 1 season rental.

We can over the cap to resign him once we have him. Dolan will pay the luxury tax no problem.

airchibundo507 @ 2/16/2012 3:55 AM
JR narrows it down to Knicks and Clippers!!

Lin(30)/Shumpert(18)
Fields(20)/JR(28)
Melo(36)/Novak(12)
Amare(32)/Jeffries(18)
Chandler(28)/Harrelson(18)

Spacing Line-up:
Lin/JR/Melo/Harrelson/Amare

Gritty Defense:
Lin/Shumpert/Melo/Jeffries/Chandler

End of close game:
Lin/JR/Melo/Amare/Chandler

airchibundo507 @ 2/16/2012 4:39 AM
airchibundo507 wrote:End of close game:
Lin/JR/Melo/Amare/Chandler

does anyone realize how potent this line-up is on offense?

two elite pnr finishers at both frontcourt spots that can knock down free throws with ease
Lin and Melo are solid outside shooters, while JR excels at it. That is ideal spacing right there.
THREE guys on the perimeter that can run the pnr.

Bring on the Heat. Bring on the Bulls. With JR we are a championship contender.

Anji @ 2/16/2012 5:17 AM
WFT kinda loaded poll is this???

We don't want or need JR Smith!!!!!!!

airchibundo507 @ 2/16/2012 5:33 AM
you want to know what playoff teams think of Fields in the clutch?

we're not going to win many close games playing 4 on 5 offense

yellowboy90 @ 2/16/2012 5:44 AM
^^^^^I forget, how did that play end?
airchibundo507 @ 2/16/2012 5:47 AM
Melo couldn't even get a shot up.
yellowboy90 @ 2/16/2012 5:57 AM
He should have passed no matter what. That same player and situation will be there again. HE needs to make that pass regardless. He has passed more in late clock situations to end quarters, like to Jorts, but he will need to lean on all his teammates in the future. You have to know the situation and it was a tie game so even if he does not make it you go into a 2nd OT but what you do as a leader if you make that pass to Fields, regardless of if he makes the basket, is you instill confidence in him for the next time. That is what Melo needs to do to become a great leader.
gunsnewing @ 2/16/2012 9:19 AM
Difference between ^that play was and what is happening now was Jeremy Lin was watching from the bench
jrodmc @ 2/16/2012 9:36 AM
And in addition to Lin, we also don't see Novak open on the opposite wing in that screenshot either do we?

Oh no, please get us JR so we can get over the hump. I hate watching the yoots gel and come together all season. I can just see JR sitting blithely on the bench watching the two nerds do the nerdy pregame thing. That should be priceless.

And adding JR to the mix certainly won't compound any issues Melo will have getting acclimated to LinWorld.

I'm sure we can just keep a tumor on the bench and in the locker room and everything will be fine all season long.

And then, when everybody's all fuhucked up, we'll be primed and ready for the playoffs.

NYKBocker @ 2/16/2012 9:55 AM
airchibundo507 wrote:you want to know what playoff teams think of Fields in the clutch?

we're not going to win many close games playing 4 on 5 offense

Replace Melo with Lin in that pic. Do you think Fields does not get the ball on a cut to the basket?

I don't want JR here but I am not voting either. Your "Nay" option suggests it is a bad thing.

technomaster @ 2/16/2012 10:15 AM
Notice that Carmelo is making a great decision by not even thinking about Tony D on the right wing.

NYKBocker wrote:
airchibundo507 wrote:you want to know what playoff teams think of Fields in the clutch?

we're not going to win many close games playing 4 on 5 offense

Replace Melo with Lin in that pic. Do you think Fields does not get the ball on a cut to the basket?

I don't want JR here but I am not voting either. Your "Nay" option suggests it is a bad thing.

sealy @ 2/16/2012 10:15 AM
jrodmc wrote:And in addition to Lin, we also don't see Novak open on the opposite wing in that screenshot either do we?

Oh no, please get us JR so we can get over the hump. I hate watching the yoots gel and come together all season. I can just see JR sitting blithely on the bench watching the two nerds do the nerdy pregame thing. That should be priceless.

And adding JR to the mix certainly won't compound any issues Melo will have getting acclimated to LinWorld.

I'm sure we can just keep a tumor on the bench and in the locker room and everything will be fine all season long.

And then, when everybody's all fuhucked up, we'll be primed and ready for the playoffs.


haha, like adding too much seasoning to an already good recipe...

yellowboy90 @ 2/16/2012 10:25 AM
NYKBocker wrote:
airchibundo507 wrote:you want to know what playoff teams think of Fields in the clutch?

we're not going to win many close games playing 4 on 5 offense

Replace Melo with Lin in that pic. Do you think Fields does not get the ball on a cut to the basket?

I don't want JR here but I am not voting either. Your "Nay" option suggests it is a bad thing.

That Picture would look different if Lin was where Melo is because they would not triple team him.

AnubisADL @ 2/16/2012 10:27 AM
This team needs shooters. Lin will get guys open looks with his penetration we need guys who can knock down shots consistently.
airchibundo507 @ 2/16/2012 10:39 AM
ESPN just said Denver GM said he's going to talk to JR about a contract.

My Gawd, JR is such a cancer

Bonn1997 @ 2/16/2012 10:50 AM
yellowboy90 wrote:
NYKBocker wrote:
airchibundo507 wrote:you want to know what playoff teams think of Fields in the clutch?

we're not going to win many close games playing 4 on 5 offense

Replace Melo with Lin in that pic. Do you think Fields does not get the ball on a cut to the basket?

I don't want JR here but I am not voting either. Your "Nay" option suggests it is a bad thing.

That Picture would look different if Lin was where Melo is because they would not triple team him.

I think you missed the point

Page 3 of 3