Knicks · Carmelo 2012, least deserving all-star in recent memory? (page 2)

Anji @ 2/27/2012 10:17 PM
Wasn't there a year were Tmac played like 10 games and made an allstar team???
crzymdups @ 2/27/2012 10:26 PM
"least deserving all-star in recent memory" had 19pts 9rebs in the all-star game somehow.
Bonn1997 @ 2/27/2012 10:27 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
crzymdups wrote:Jamaal Magloire is the least deserving all-star in recent memory.

Next question.

DUDE TWICE!! that was the year Centers where on the declind, and Zo had the kidney ailment..

but really, what other SF in the east is better then melo even when he's playing @75%


Just looked at the rosters closely. I'd rank Melo higher than I thought I was going to actually this year. I'd put him behind only Pierce, Lebron, and Iggy for the season.
arkrud @ 2/28/2012 12:11 AM
crzymdups wrote:"least deserving all-star in recent memory" had 19pts 9rebs in the all-star game somehow.

All stars who never pass the ball should have a lot of points in All-star game so it is expected.
Melo is Melo... the scoring machine with 40% efficiency. So on average team with him as primary scorer should be around 50/50 with exit from 1st round.

airchibundo507 @ 2/28/2012 1:29 AM
arkrud wrote:
crzymdups wrote:"least deserving all-star in recent memory" had 19pts 9rebs in the all-star game somehow.

All stars who never pass the ball should have a lot of points in All-star game so it is expected.
Melo is Melo... the scoring machine with 40% efficiency. So on average team with him as primary scorer should be around 50/50 with exit from 1st round.

yeah, Melo was the only selfish all-star. [/sarcasm]

He had the highest +/- on the East squad btw, even playing out of position.

skeng @ 2/28/2012 6:53 AM
Anji wrote:Wasn't there a year were Tmac played like 10 games and made an allstar team???

Together with Yao, they dominated the all star game votings. Yao was voted on even though he was done for the whole season.

DurzoBlint @ 2/28/2012 7:46 AM
Didn't Vince Carters once play his 1st game of the season at the AS Game.
MarburyAnd1Crossover @ 2/28/2012 8:24 AM
airchibundo507 wrote:
arkrud wrote:
crzymdups wrote:"least deserving all-star in recent memory" had 19pts 9rebs in the all-star game somehow.

All stars who never pass the ball should have a lot of points in All-star game so it is expected.
Melo is Melo... the scoring machine with 40% efficiency. So on average team with him as primary scorer should be around 50/50 with exit from 1st round.

yeah, Melo was the only selfish all-star. [/sarcasm]

He had the highest +/- on the East squad btw, even playing out of position.

I KNOW you're not citing AS Game stats to back your guy up!

JCrusher @ 2/28/2012 9:16 AM
all-star voting doesn't mean that much as we have seen so I dont care who is picked. I mean yes melo had had a bad year but he has had a successful career so he is gonna be picked on that. I just want our team to get quickly and move up in te standings
Page 2 of 2