fishmike wrote:how about just keeping him so we can get 20ppg 8rebs and 55% scoring from our PF? Just a thought...
What a novel concept. I swear, the moment a player comes to NY, we don't want him anymore and want to trade him for below his value. We are not getting good value for Amar'e, so let's just keep him. Amar'e + Melo + Tyson + Lin is our best option at making a playoff run, let's just go with the hand we have.
Solace wrote:fishmike wrote:how about just keeping him so we can get 20ppg 8rebs and 55% scoring from our PF? Just a thought...
What a novel concept. I swear, the moment a player comes to NY, we don't want him anymore and want to trade him for below his value. We are not getting good value for Amar'e, so let's just keep him. Amar'e + Melo + Tyson + Lin is our best option at making a playoff run, let's just go with the hand we have.
I don't think we can trade Amare either but nor am I happy with a guy making $20M to put up 18 pts - 8 rebounds a game. I criticize Melo for not playing to his contract expectations and I criticize Amare just the same. In the NBA because of the salary cap you have to make every payroll dollar count. Currently 60% of our cap is tied up on two players who clearly are not able to justify that value. This is why you keep seeing trade proposals.
How about we all just wait for a full training camp with Lin running the show and see how STAT plays? The guy is far from finished.
loweyecue wrote:Solace wrote:fishmike wrote:how about just keeping him so we can get 20ppg 8rebs and 55% scoring from our PF? Just a thought...
What a novel concept. I swear, the moment a player comes to NY, we don't want him anymore and want to trade him for below his value. We are not getting good value for Amar'e, so let's just keep him. Amar'e + Melo + Tyson + Lin is our best option at making a playoff run, let's just go with the hand we have.
I don't think we can trade Amare either but nor am I happy with a guy making $20M to put up 18 pts - 8 rebounds a game. I criticize Melo for not playing to his contract expectations and I criticize Amare just the same. In the NBA because of the salary cap you have to make every payroll dollar count. Currently 60% of our cap is tied up on two players who clearly are not able to justify that value. This is why you keep seeing trade proposals.
I hear you, but do you think anyone on this board is going to be happy with Andrea Bargnani?
Solace wrote:loweyecue wrote:Solace wrote:fishmike wrote:how about just keeping him so we can get 20ppg 8rebs and 55% scoring from our PF? Just a thought...
What a novel concept. I swear, the moment a player comes to NY, we don't want him anymore and want to trade him for below his value. We are not getting good value for Amar'e, so let's just keep him. Amar'e + Melo + Tyson + Lin is our best option at making a playoff run, let's just go with the hand we have.
I don't think we can trade Amare either but nor am I happy with a guy making $20M to put up 18 pts - 8 rebounds a game. I criticize Melo for not playing to his contract expectations and I criticize Amare just the same. In the NBA because of the salary cap you have to make every payroll dollar count. Currently 60% of our cap is tied up on two players who clearly are not able to justify that value. This is why you keep seeing trade proposals.
I hear you, but do you think anyone on this board is going to be happy with Andrea Bargnani? 
I know Gallo lovers would pick up right where they left off.
Vmart wrote:Solace wrote:loweyecue wrote:Solace wrote:fishmike wrote:how about just keeping him so we can get 20ppg 8rebs and 55% scoring from our PF? Just a thought...
What a novel concept. I swear, the moment a player comes to NY, we don't want him anymore and want to trade him for below his value. We are not getting good value for Amar'e, so let's just keep him. Amar'e + Melo + Tyson + Lin is our best option at making a playoff run, let's just go with the hand we have.
I don't think we can trade Amare either but nor am I happy with a guy making $20M to put up 18 pts - 8 rebounds a game. I criticize Melo for not playing to his contract expectations and I criticize Amare just the same. In the NBA because of the salary cap you have to make every payroll dollar count. Currently 60% of our cap is tied up on two players who clearly are not able to justify that value. This is why you keep seeing trade proposals.
I hear you, but do you think anyone on this board is going to be happy with Andrea Bargnani? 
I know Gallo lovers would pick up right where they left off.
Nice try. The answer is no. This guy would get torn apart here if we traded Amar'e for him.
Bargnani:
Scoring efficiency: slightly below average
Rebounding: way below average
Passing: below average
Steals: below average
Shot-blocking: slightly below average
He is the kind of player you stay far away from. He doesn't do anything well.
Solace wrote:Vmart wrote:Solace wrote:loweyecue wrote:Solace wrote:fishmike wrote:how about just keeping him so we can get 20ppg 8rebs and 55% scoring from our PF? Just a thought...
What a novel concept. I swear, the moment a player comes to NY, we don't want him anymore and want to trade him for below his value. We are not getting good value for Amar'e, so let's just keep him. Amar'e + Melo + Tyson + Lin is our best option at making a playoff run, let's just go with the hand we have.
I don't think we can trade Amare either but nor am I happy with a guy making $20M to put up 18 pts - 8 rebounds a game. I criticize Melo for not playing to his contract expectations and I criticize Amare just the same. In the NBA because of the salary cap you have to make every payroll dollar count. Currently 60% of our cap is tied up on two players who clearly are not able to justify that value. This is why you keep seeing trade proposals.
I hear you, but do you think anyone on this board is going to be happy with Andrea Bargnani? 
I know Gallo lovers would pick up right where they left off.
Nice try. The answer is no. This guy would get torn apart here if we traded Amar'e for him.
Just like Melo is getting torn apart for being traded for Gallo right.
I wondered if NO would do a Okafur and Arzia for Stat trade.
That would help fill out the bench nicely. Sign Odom to start
That team could go all in on getting it's offense out of Melo/Lin/JR
Lin/Shumps
TR/JR
Melo/Fields or JJ2
Odom/Novack or JJ2
Chandler/Ok4