Nash cant defend a chair at this point. Drop 15 give up 20.
We can add Kidd, Camby and instantly be the oldest team in the league...
AnubisADL wrote:Nash cant defend a chair at this point. Drop 15 give up 20.
Well if he also helps Amare average 24+, helps Ty get easy baskets and keeps Melo happy, it might not matter.
Nash couldnt win in his prime with joe Johnson,Amare ,marion and a better bench so no he wont win us a championship. We might win a playoff round if we dont play Miami,Chicago,or Boston or Brooklyn with Howard
Exactly I've said that before. Nash and amare in their prime couldnt win nevermind at 40 and a broken down amare. No joe johnson & marion!
gunsnewing wrote:Exactly I've said that before. Nash and amare in their prime couldnt win nevermind at 40 and a broken down amare. No joe johnson & marion!
If shumpert score 20 ppg to go along with his great defense and he didnt get hrt all the time i would agree but shump has no offensive game and he gets hurt a lot
Shump was a rookie incase u didnt notice man
gunsnewing wrote:Shump was a rookie incase u didnt notice man
Um I know thatt did i say he was a veteran?
We are trading for a 40yr old. Can we for once not get hosed in a deal and give up just TD, jj3 & jorts
IrishKnickFan wrote:gunsnewing wrote:Exactly I've said that before. Nash and amare in their prime couldnt win nevermind at 40 and a broken down amare. No joe johnson & marion!
If shumpert score 20 ppg to go along with his great defense and he didnt get hrt all the time i would agree but shump has no offensive game and he gets hurt a lot
No offensive game? Shump was developing as a scorer toward the end of the season. To the point where it was gonna be scary to see him after a full summer of off season workouts. I don't think Shump is fragile either. You have to take into account that he played in a shortened season during his rookie year.
gunsnewing wrote:We are trading for a 40yr old. Can we for once not get hosed in a deal and give up just TD, jj3 & jorts
That's what I'm saying. Or if he can just come out and say he wants to play for NY maybe we can try and find a third team.
With the Melo trade everyone was saying the same thing for Melo if you have to give up chandler or gallo you have to do it. Melo was only 25 & in his prime star! Its the same vicious cycle if Dolan playing the fans.
How many knicks fans now wish we held onto one of the two gallo or wilson
Not only do we not get a ring, but we have another fire sale, clearing out every draft pick of the last 3 years. Getting old fast
He gets us at the door...then anything can happen
He gets us much closer than an injured shump
helloharv wrote:He gets us at the door...then anything can happenHe gets us much closer than an injured shump
Yeah some feel shumpert will help us more tahn nash despite the fact that shump will miss most if not all of the next year
AnubisADL wrote:Nash cant defend a chair at this point. Drop 15 give up 20.
Nash will lock down rondo, dwill, dwade and Westbrook. 
nobody locks those guys down, nor do they lock each other down.
Im not a fan of the trade but to simply say they did not do it in PHX then it won't happen here is not quite what is going on.
They ran into good laker and Spurs teams for one. And we might be the same running into good Miami and Chicago this time around.
I can live with it but I don't want to lose Lin.
Losing Lin, Lando and shump all at once would leave old, and older going forward with no picks.
The backbone of this team was the youth assets that were traded and if don't get a ring in the next two years we are possibly screwed for a few years after.
Does that matter anymore? Apparently not. Might say the same for Miami, Boston and Nets.
ATrain wrote:IrishKnickFan wrote:gunsnewing wrote:Exactly I've said that before. Nash and amare in their prime couldnt win nevermind at 40 and a broken down amare. No joe johnson & marion!
If shumpert score 20 ppg to go along with his great defense and he didnt get hrt all the time i would agree but shump has no offensive game and he gets hurt a lot
No offensive game? Shump was developing as a scorer toward the end of the season. To the point where it was gonna be scary to see him after a full summer of off season workouts. I don't think Shump is fragile either. You have to take into account that he played in a shortened season during his rookie year.
Who even cares about his offensive game? That's why we have Melo, Amare, and Lin. He's our only lockdown wing defender and one of the only ones in the entire NBA.
gunsnewing wrote:With the Melo trade everyone was saying the same thing for Melo if you have to give up chandler or gallo you have to do it. Melo was only 25 & in his prime star! Its the same vicious cycle if Dolan playing the fans.How many knicks fans now wish we held onto one of the two gallo or wilson
I dont because bottom line u can trade Melo tomorrow for better players then those 2
IrishKnickFan wrote:helloharv wrote:He gets us at the door...then anything can happenHe gets us much closer than an injured shump
Yeah some feel shumpert will help us more tahn nash despite the fact that shump will miss most if not all of the next year
where did u read he is missing the entire year. Last I heard he is shooting for jan
The fans here all they want is a East conf final appearance OR a NBA Final appearance
even as underdogs Knicks fans will sadly settle for that
Sad
You're not getting NAsh to be a knick savior and speculative defender team to improve much
what is going on here ? 50 win Knick season ? and bounce from round 1 or 2 in playoffs?
As all we getting with Nash future hall of famer
Nash will be 40 yrs old then by time Knicks fail with PG Nash and roster of Amare + MElo in mix
Nash didnt get it done in Arizona,
sure not at Texas(Mavs) when he developed his skills. He is a great player but knicks need pieces like
Shumpert and when we get a guy whom loves to play D we chuck him out for a over 37 yr old star with 2-3 yrs left in
nba world.
Makes no sense, I will always love the knicks and wont be a fake fan but I'd say
if all these rumor changes happen it be hard for DJ to watch NYK hoops next few seasons.
