Knicks · Donnie Walsh What were you thinking???? (page 1)

gunsnewing @ 1/27/2013 3:06 AM
Drafting Jordan Hill over

Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Disgrace palm

Cartman718 @ 1/27/2013 3:16 AM
gunsnewing wrote:Drafting Jordan Hill over

Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Disgrace palm

maybe he was thinking nash and amare back together under d'antoni. :)

gunsnewing @ 1/27/2013 3:20 AM
And with Dantoni as your coach and in desperate need of a PG for 4yrs!!!!!!
Anji @ 1/27/2013 3:24 AM
We talking 2009 draft??? Yep, nobody depressed here.........
Caseloads @ 1/27/2013 3:33 AM
Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Those guys would have been thrown in with a trade or never allowed to develop here.

smackeddog @ 1/27/2013 3:53 AM
Caseloads wrote:Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Those guys would have been thrown in with a trade or never allowed to develop here.

Yeah, that's what I seek solace in- even if we had drafted Jrue or Ty (don't like Jennings), we'd never have let them develop- would have ended up getting traded in some sort of starphuck.

Mray20 @ 1/27/2013 4:33 AM
smackeddog wrote:
Caseloads wrote:Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Those guys would have been thrown in with a trade or never allowed to develop here.

Yeah, that's what I seek solace in- even if we had drafted Jrue or Ty (don't like Jennings), we'd never have let them develop- would have ended up getting traded in some sort of starphuck.


They would have went in the Melo trade
VCoug @ 1/27/2013 7:56 AM
Mray20 wrote:
smackeddog wrote:
Caseloads wrote:Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Those guys would have been thrown in with a trade or never allowed to develop here.

Yeah, that's what I seek solace in- even if we had drafted Jrue or Ty (don't like Jennings), we'd never have let them develop- would have ended up getting traded in some sort of starphuck.


They would have went in the Melo trade

Or the one to dump Jeffries.

Jmpasq @ 1/27/2013 8:35 AM
Mray20 wrote:
smackeddog wrote:
Caseloads wrote:Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Those guys would have been thrown in with a trade or never allowed to develop here.

Yeah, that's what I seek solace in- even if we had drafted Jrue or Ty (don't like Jennings), we'd never have let them develop- would have ended up getting traded in some sort of starphuck.


They would have went in the Melo trade

Yes they would of been traded but maybe they wouldnt of had to give up an extra draft choice or another player in the trade. Im pretty sure everyone hated the Jordan Hill pick. Ive hated alot of Knicks picks. The only 1 i was wrong about was Shumpert who was much better than I thought he would be.
Nalod @ 1/27/2013 9:12 AM
gunsnewing wrote:Drafting Jordan Hill over

Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Disgrace palm

He had Lebron on his mind.

MInd you others those guys fall also.

He was thinking of drafting a senior who could be NBA ready. Those guys were not. Guns, you really want do the "hindsight Draft Lament" thing? You'd have to draft a player and develop him. Holiday needed time, Jennings would have been crushed in the NY media for his inconsistant play and Ty was always gettng hurt.

Im with you but we don't draft players and keep them too often.

GustavBahler @ 1/27/2013 10:44 AM
Can't blame you for being upset about Holiday and Lawson but not Jennings. We were just getting through the Marbury era and Jennings was acting like the jr. version before the draft. I can't blame Donnie for not wanting to go that route. I didn't get the Jordan Hill pick either since we had someone on the team at the time who pretty much had the same skill set in Chris Wilcox. Didn't seem like much thought went into it.
tkf @ 1/27/2013 11:17 AM
gunsnewing wrote:Drafting Jordan Hill over

Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Disgrace palm

a few gm's passed on lawson, he surprised even me... I was never that big a fan of jennings.. Jrue Holliday walsh liked, but he was so young.. doesn't matter this organization doesn't have patience.. Jrue would have been traded in another starphuch deal anyway....

KnicksFE @ 1/27/2013 11:19 AM
Jmpasq wrote:
Mray20 wrote:
smackeddog wrote:
Caseloads wrote:Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Those guys would have been thrown in with a trade or never allowed to develop here.

Yeah, that's what I seek solace in- even if we had drafted Jrue or Ty (don't like Jennings), we'd never have let them develop- would have ended up getting traded in some sort of starphuck.


They would have went in the Melo trade

Yes they would of been traded but maybe they wouldnt of had to give up an extra draft choice or another player in the trade. Im pretty sure everyone hated the Jordan Hill pick. Ive hated alot of Knicks picks. The only 1 i was wrong about was Shumpert who was much better than I thought he would be.

And Shumpert almost got traded to the Suns last offseason, lucky for us, the Lakers saved us on this one.

gunsnewing @ 1/27/2013 11:20 AM
It is really hard to root for this organization. What a joke
misterearl @ 1/27/2013 11:26 AM
gunsnewing wrote:It is really hard to root for this organization. What a joke

You can always change the channel.

Try something easy

Caseloads @ 1/27/2013 12:30 PM
KnicksFE wrote:
Jmpasq wrote:
Mray20 wrote:
smackeddog wrote:
Caseloads wrote:Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Those guys would have been thrown in with a trade or never allowed to develop here.

Yeah, that's what I seek solace in- even if we had drafted Jrue or Ty (don't like Jennings), we'd never have let them develop- would have ended up getting traded in some sort of starphuck.


They would have went in the Melo trade

Yes they would of been traded but maybe they wouldnt of had to give up an extra draft choice or another player in the trade. Im pretty sure everyone hated the Jordan Hill pick. Ive hated alot of Knicks picks. The only 1 i was wrong about was Shumpert who was much better than I thought he would be.

And Shumpert almost got traded to the Suns last offseason, lucky for us, the Lakers saved us on this one.


That was a bullet dodged. Nash is done.
MSG3 @ 1/27/2013 12:39 PM
Caseloads wrote:
KnicksFE wrote:
Jmpasq wrote:
Mray20 wrote:
smackeddog wrote:
Caseloads wrote:Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Those guys would have been thrown in with a trade or never allowed to develop here.

Yeah, that's what I seek solace in- even if we had drafted Jrue or Ty (don't like Jennings), we'd never have let them develop- would have ended up getting traded in some sort of starphuck.


They would have went in the Melo trade

Yes they would of been traded but maybe they wouldnt of had to give up an extra draft choice or another player in the trade. Im pretty sure everyone hated the Jordan Hill pick. Ive hated alot of Knicks picks. The only 1 i was wrong about was Shumpert who was much better than I thought he would be.

And Shumpert almost got traded to the Suns last offseason, lucky for us, the Lakers saved us on this one.


That was a bullet dodged. Nash is done.

Seriously. Nash isn't getting any heat for the Lakers problems. He finally looks his age.

jrodmc @ 1/28/2013 9:04 AM
misterearl wrote:
gunsnewing wrote:It is really hard to root for this organization. What a joke

You can always change the channel.

Try something easy

It would probably be entertaining to watch the Sombers be the vocal Homer contingent on those other team's boards.

Standard default thread titles:
"YEAH, WE MIGHT BE MIDDLE OF THE PACK, BUT AT LEAST WE'RE NOT THE KNICKS!"

"FLEXIBILITY! MAN, I LOVE THIS TEAM!"

"ONLY nnn DAYS UNTIL DRAFT NIGHT!"

"Poll: WHICH FRANCHISE DO YOU WISH MELO ON MORE THAN THE KNICKS?"

"WHY OUR BENCH IS CONSTRUCTED WITH THE NEXT 20 YEARS IN MIND"

"THE TOP 2000 DIFFERENT POSSIBILE TRADE SCENARIOS THAT PRESERVE OUR ABILITY TO HAVE TRADE SCENARIOS"

"WE'RE TOP TEN IN SCORING EFFICIENCY WITH TEAMS THAT HAVE LEFT HANDED PG'S!"

fishmike @ 1/28/2013 9:27 AM
gunsnewing wrote:Drafting Jordan Hill over

Jrue Holiday
Brandon Jennings
Ty Lawson

Disgrace palm

we have Melo now. What else matters?
Page 1 of 1