Knicks · Re: FA Signings versus trade (page 1)

Caseloads @ 7/5/2016 10:23 PM
"Something new to cover? You missed a detail that hasn't been talked about over the last, what, 5 years?" - Martin

Yes - it stands to reason, that if you want to go to a new team, don't decimate that new team via trade.

Look, Durant didn't demand a sign and trade MAX from OKC to GS. This is the new stuff. He could have said to trade Barnes and Bogut to OKC so he could sign for 5 year max (not taking into account the new contracts coming next year).

With the Melo trade, yes, we got him, but he was coming here anyway.

It's the same thing with Russell Westbrook - hope we DO NOT trade for him. If he wants to come here, sign him outright. Although, ROSE is likely better for this team than RUSS. RUSS upset Durant and is one of the reasons DURANT left. Maybe the chemistry between RUSS and MELO may not be good.

Hope ROSE is healthy, otherwise, go get CP3 next year. Better for chemistry than Russ in my opinion.

martin @ 7/5/2016 10:33 PM
Caseloads wrote:"Something new to cover? You missed a detail that hasn't been talked about over the last, what, 5 years?" - Martin

Yes - it stands to reason, that if you want to go to a new team, don't decimate that new team via trade.

Look, Durant didn't demand a sign and trade MAX from OKC to GS. This is the new stuff. He could have said to trade Barnes and Bogut to OKC so he could sign for 5 year max (not taking into account the new contracts coming next year).

With the Melo trade, yes, we got him, but he was coming here anyway.

It's the same thing with Russell Westbrook - hope we DO NOT trade for him. If he wants to come here, sign him outright. Although, ROSE is likely better for this team than RUSS. RUSS upset Durant and is one of the reasons DURANT left. Maybe the chemistry between RUSS and MELO may not be good.

Hope ROSE is healthy, otherwise, go get CP3 next year. Better for chemistry than Russ in my opinion.

Great. What more are we adding? You just stated the obvious. What else? Re-hashing 5 years ago has no bearing on today and the new market of astronomical salaries.

BigRedDog @ 7/5/2016 10:43 PM
Caseloads get back on your medication. WTF???
Knickoftime @ 7/5/2016 11:20 PM
Caseloads wrote:Look, Durant didn't demand a sign and trade MAX from OKC to GS. This is the new stuff. He could have said to trade Barnes and Bogut to OKC so he could sign for 5 year max (not taking into account the new contracts coming next year).

No, he did not.

But the Warriors have to get rid of them anyway to make cap room for him.

Which is the parallel to the Melo trade the people who can't let it go 5 years later almost universally don't understand.

It's not funny anymore.

If you're going to rehash it again and again, at least educate yourself what actually happened first.

CrushAlot @ 7/5/2016 11:26 PM
I didn't realize this was part 2 of the locked thread.
Welpee @ 7/6/2016 8:24 AM
If Melo was so set on coming to the Knicks why did he also entertain going to the Brooklyn?
Page 1 of 1