Knicks · Berman on Filmschool Pod from Last Week Predicted Melo will be Knick next year (page 1)

CrushAlot @ 3/14/2020 2:55 PM
Macri asked him to make one prediction. He said Melo will be a Knick. Said Leon tried to get Melo on the Knicks last offseason, Melo wants to be here and Rose wants him to finish his career as a Knick. Berman also said he thinks Leon will bring some star power to the Knicks next year.
knicks1248 @ 3/17/2020 8:20 AM
CrushAlot wrote:Macri asked him to make one prediction. He said Melo will be a Knick. Said Leon tried to get Melo on the Knicks last offseason, Melo wants to be here and Rose wants him to finish his career as a Knick. Berman also said he thinks Leon will bring some star power to the Knicks next year.

The youth movement is out the window once you bring melo back and add a star (perhaps cp)

jrodmc @ 3/17/2020 10:27 AM
knicks1248 wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:Macri asked him to make one prediction. He said Melo will be a Knick. Said Leon tried to get Melo on the Knicks last offseason, Melo wants to be here and Rose wants him to finish his career as a Knick. Berman also said he thinks Leon will bring some star power to the Knicks next year.

The youth movement is out the window once you bring melo back and add a star (perhaps cp)

Yeah, because we're just loaded up with yoots desperate for development at PF. WTF are you talking about?

GustavBahler @ 3/17/2020 12:49 PM
Probably all.but a done deal. Guessing mgmt believes fans will want to turn the clock back a bit and bring Melo back in part for sentimantal reasons. Times being what they are now. I hope we have a team good enough to make Melo not mind coming off the bench. Not too keen on Melo starting. Not sentimental for ISO ball.
CrushAlot @ 3/17/2020 1:51 PM
GustavBahler wrote:Probably all.but a done deal. Guessing mgmt believes fans will want to turn the clock back a bit and bring Melo back in part for sentimantal reasons. Times being what they are now. I hope we have a team good enough to make Melo not mind coming off the bench. Not too keen on Melo starting. Not sentimental for ISO ball.
I feel the same way. I enjoyed Melo's time in NY but it has passed. I don't see him taking on a Vince Carter type role but I could be wrong. He also may not be ready to retire after next year. I thought it was interesting that Berman thinks Rose will bring in some star power to MSG.
Knixkik @ 3/17/2020 2:01 PM
Melo is likely coming back. I think his hiatus humbled him a bit and he just wants to play and help these guys. Hopefully thats the case at least.
knicks1248 @ 3/17/2020 2:42 PM
CrushAlot wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:Probably all.but a done deal. Guessing mgmt believes fans will want to turn the clock back a bit and bring Melo back in part for sentimantal reasons. Times being what they are now. I hope we have a team good enough to make Melo not mind coming off the bench. Not too keen on Melo starting. Not sentimental for ISO ball.
I feel the same way. I enjoyed Melo's time in NY but it has passed. I don't see him taking on a Vince Carter type role but I could be wrong. He also may not be ready to retire after next year. I thought it was interesting that Berman thinks Rose will bring in some star power to MSG.

why wouldn't he?

knicks1248 @ 3/17/2020 2:44 PM
jrodmc wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:Macri asked him to make one prediction. He said Melo will be a Knick. Said Leon tried to get Melo on the Knicks last offseason, Melo wants to be here and Rose wants him to finish his career as a Knick. Berman also said he thinks Leon will bring some star power to the Knicks next year.

The youth movement is out the window once you bring melo back and add a star (perhaps cp)

Yeah, because we're just loaded up with yoots desperate for development at PF. WTF are you talking about?

Even if he brings in thibs, does anyone of our young guys look strong enough to handle the minutes he gives starters..

jrodmc @ 3/17/2020 2:59 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
jrodmc wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:Macri asked him to make one prediction. He said Melo will be a Knick. Said Leon tried to get Melo on the Knicks last offseason, Melo wants to be here and Rose wants him to finish his career as a Knick. Berman also said he thinks Leon will bring some star power to the Knicks next year.

The youth movement is out the window once you bring melo back and add a star (perhaps cp)

Yeah, because we're just loaded up with yoots desperate for development at PF. WTF are you talking about?

Even if he brings in thibs, does anyone of our young guys look strong enough to handle the minutes he gives starters..

You said melo and any other star would mean yoots are out the window. What the hell does thibs have to do with this?

What if Dolan brings in Cuban as part owner? What if Spike Lee becomes Leon's chief development architect? What if the Felt Forum is actually a front for the Ukrainian underworld? I used to ignore most of the drunk uncle comments about your posts, but man you really are reaching sometimes... are you normally lighting up before you post?

jrodmc @ 3/17/2020 3:03 PM
Knixkik wrote:Melo is likely coming back. I think his hiatus humbled him a bit and he just wants to play and help these guys. Hopefully thats the case at least.

Agreed.
His FGA are way down for the most part (despite playing over 30 mpg), and I haven't read anything about him being anything but a good soldier playing with that stellar backcourt and staying out of Whiteside's way.

Hope that continues when (and if) he's playing with our group of not-as-talented yoots.

Nalod @ 3/17/2020 5:47 PM
Rose the agent wanted what was best for Melo.
Leon the professional (LTP) wants whats best for the knicks.
Does Drunk uncle the MIT genius with Thibs, the swinging batchler bartender has to restep everthing they ever done and replicate it going forward.

I can't predict what in the hell LTP does but we got folk that got him pegged. In fact what have we learned from some of our esteemed contributors:

1. CP3 had his best year in a few. He suprised everyone. Where last year Rockets had to send him with a treasure trove of picks and Gallo AND SGA! to OKC for Westbrook. Seven picks to be exact. Now, knicks should get him.
2. Melo was on the scrap heap. Admittingly he has surpassed most expectations. Playing with Dame and Mcallum he is pretty good. Team still won't make playoffs but, they are decent'

So.........add it up. Since we can't rebuild, we should not try. Trade for CP3 and the insane contract with two years and 85 mil on it, and BRING IN MELO. Top it off, birng in Thibs and see the Phantom of the Opera run them in the ground? Fucking brilliant! WHen MS meets Rainman.

GustavBahler @ 3/17/2020 7:52 PM
CrushAlot wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:Probably all.but a done deal. Guessing mgmt believes fans will want to turn the clock back a bit and bring Melo back in part for sentimantal reasons. Times being what they are now. I hope we have a team good enough to make Melo not mind coming off the bench. Not too keen on Melo starting. Not sentimental for ISO ball.
I feel the same way. I enjoyed Melo's time in NY but it has passed. I don't see him taking on a Vince Carter type role but I could be wrong. He also may not be ready to retire after next year. I thought it was interesting that Berman thinks Rose will bring in some star power to MSG.

We saw Melo lead the team in assists for a season. We talk about "Olympic Melo" Id be happy with that Melo who was looking to get everyone involved. It could happen. Just dont want to see Melo get an outsized role in the offense.

Dont know what Berman is basing this on, but I hope he's right about star power. Have to give credit to Perry for giving the Knicks the flexibilty to do that

Nalod @ 3/18/2020 7:29 AM
GustavBahler wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:Probably all.but a done deal. Guessing mgmt believes fans will want to turn the clock back a bit and bring Melo back in part for sentimantal reasons. Times being what they are now. I hope we have a team good enough to make Melo not mind coming off the bench. Not too keen on Melo starting. Not sentimental for ISO ball.
I feel the same way. I enjoyed Melo's time in NY but it has passed. I don't see him taking on a Vince Carter type role but I could be wrong. He also may not be ready to retire after next year. I thought it was interesting that Berman thinks Rose will bring in some star power to MSG.

We saw Melo lead the team in assists for a season. We talk about "Olympic Melo" Id be happy with that Melo who was looking to get everyone involved. It could happen. Just dont want to see Melo get an outsized role in the offense.

Dont know what Berman is basing this on, but I hope he's right about star power. Have to give credit to Perry for giving the Knicks the flexibilty to do that



Perry “Gave the knicks flex”? Really? Like a gift? OR Devine intervention? Or Defied Mills? Or The owner told him to keep it all open as he did with Layden before Isiah cashed it all in? I do like this build up of assets and its gong to be interesting if, how and when they use it.
GustavBahler @ 3/18/2020 10:12 AM
Nalod wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:Probably all.but a done deal. Guessing mgmt believes fans will want to turn the clock back a bit and bring Melo back in part for sentimantal reasons. Times being what they are now. I hope we have a team good enough to make Melo not mind coming off the bench. Not too keen on Melo starting. Not sentimental for ISO ball.
I feel the same way. I enjoyed Melo's time in NY but it has passed. I don't see him taking on a Vince Carter type role but I could be wrong. He also may not be ready to retire after next year. I thought it was interesting that Berman thinks Rose will bring in some star power to MSG.

We saw Melo lead the team in assists for a season. We talk about "Olympic Melo" Id be happy with that Melo who was looking to get everyone involved. It could happen. Just dont want to see Melo get an outsized role in the offense.

Dont know what Berman is basing this on, but I hope he's right about star power. Have to give credit to Perry for giving the Knicks the flexibilty to do that



Perry “Gave the knicks flex”? Really? Like a gift? OR Devine intervention? Or Defied Mills? Or The owner told him to keep it all open as he did with Layden before Isiah cashed it all in? I do like this build up of assets and its gong to be interesting if, how and when they use it.

Yes, really. What did Mills do between the time Phil was fired, and Perry was hired? Sign Baker to how much? Sign Hardaway for how much?

Dont believe its a coincidence that the deals got better for NY's cap flexibilty after Perry was hired. You want to praise Mills again, be my guest. I didnt see that discipline pre-Perry.

Nalod @ 3/18/2020 11:45 AM
GustavBahler wrote:
Nalod wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:Probably all.but a done deal. Guessing mgmt believes fans will want to turn the clock back a bit and bring Melo back in part for sentimantal reasons. Times being what they are now. I hope we have a team good enough to make Melo not mind coming off the bench. Not too keen on Melo starting. Not sentimental for ISO ball.
I feel the same way. I enjoyed Melo's time in NY but it has passed. I don't see him taking on a Vince Carter type role but I could be wrong. He also may not be ready to retire after next year. I thought it was interesting that Berman thinks Rose will bring in some star power to MSG.

We saw Melo lead the team in assists for a season. We talk about "Olympic Melo" Id be happy with that Melo who was looking to get everyone involved. It could happen. Just dont want to see Melo get an outsized role in the offense.

Dont know what Berman is basing this on, but I hope he's right about star power. Have to give credit to Perry for giving the Knicks the flexibilty to do that



Perry “Gave the knicks flex”? Really? Like a gift? OR Devine intervention? Or Defied Mills? Or The owner told him to keep it all open as he did with Layden before Isiah cashed it all in? I do like this build up of assets and its gong to be interesting if, how and when they use it.

Yes, really. What did Mills do between the time Phil was fired, and Perry was hired? Sign Baker to how much? Sign Hardaway for how much?

Dont believe its a coincidence that the deals got better for NY's cap flexibilty after Perry was hired. You want to praise Mills again, be my guest. I didnt see that discipline pre-Perry.

Relax......
My point is not about MIlls and Baker, its not Perry driving the ship. ITs the directive to accumulate assets.
I’m not defending mills. Records speak for itself. Let’s not even go to the place who did what. Let’s just say “Knicks signed Morris”.....and thats “Knicks got a good return”. Just normal decisions.
Who drove the KP bus? Phil wanted him traded, Dolan nixed it.
Blame Mills for the aftermath, no IM blaming “Knicks”.
I like Perry, but I don’t the directive as much as you do.
PErry does not set the goals of the team. He might execute it better.

GustavBahler @ 3/18/2020 11:58 AM
Nalod wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:
Nalod wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:Probably all.but a done deal. Guessing mgmt believes fans will want to turn the clock back a bit and bring Melo back in part for sentimantal reasons. Times being what they are now. I hope we have a team good enough to make Melo not mind coming off the bench. Not too keen on Melo starting. Not sentimental for ISO ball.
I feel the same way. I enjoyed Melo's time in NY but it has passed. I don't see him taking on a Vince Carter type role but I could be wrong. He also may not be ready to retire after next year. I thought it was interesting that Berman thinks Rose will bring in some star power to MSG.

We saw Melo lead the team in assists for a season. We talk about "Olympic Melo" Id be happy with that Melo who was looking to get everyone involved. It could happen. Just dont want to see Melo get an outsized role in the offense.

Dont know what Berman is basing this on, but I hope he's right about star power. Have to give credit to Perry for giving the Knicks the flexibilty to do that



Perry “Gave the knicks flex”? Really? Like a gift? OR Devine intervention? Or Defied Mills? Or The owner told him to keep it all open as he did with Layden before Isiah cashed it all in? I do like this build up of assets and its gong to be interesting if, how and when they use it.

Yes, really. What did Mills do between the time Phil was fired, and Perry was hired? Sign Baker to how much? Sign Hardaway for how much?

Dont believe its a coincidence that the deals got better for NY's cap flexibilty after Perry was hired. You want to praise Mills again, be my guest. I didnt see that discipline pre-Perry.

Relax......
My point is not about MIlls and Baker, its not Perry driving the ship. ITs the directive to accumulate assets.
I’m not defending mills. Records speak for itself. Let’s not even go to the place who did what. Let’s just say “Knicks signed Morris”.....and thats “Knicks got a good return”. Just normal decisions.
Who drove the KP bus? Phil wanted him traded, Dolan nixed it.
Blame Mills for the aftermath, no IM blaming “Knicks”.
I like Perry, but I don’t the directive as much as you do.
PErry does not set the goals of the team. He might execute it better.

Quite calm thanks. Im used to the reflexive defense of Mills by now. Talking about fiscal discipline and practicing it are two different things. Phil talked about it, then went for the quick fix. Signed Noah(a bench player at that point) to a ridiculous deal, still on the books . Mills talked about it, and in that great Knick tradition, also bid against himself.

CrushAlot @ 3/23/2020 1:45 PM
Knixkik @ 3/24/2020 9:17 AM
I'm really only interested in Melo if we move Randle. Not interested in seeing Randle and Melo takes turns playing iso. But Melo off the bench as a bucket getter is reasonable if there's no other iso players.
jrodmc @ 3/24/2020 9:25 AM
GustavBahler wrote:
Nalod wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:
Nalod wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:Probably all.but a done deal. Guessing mgmt believes fans will want to turn the clock back a bit and bring Melo back in part for sentimantal reasons. Times being what they are now. I hope we have a team good enough to make Melo not mind coming off the bench. Not too keen on Melo starting. Not sentimental for ISO ball.
I feel the same way. I enjoyed Melo's time in NY but it has passed. I don't see him taking on a Vince Carter type role but I could be wrong. He also may not be ready to retire after next year. I thought it was interesting that Berman thinks Rose will bring in some star power to MSG.

We saw Melo lead the team in assists for a season. We talk about "Olympic Melo" Id be happy with that Melo who was looking to get everyone involved. It could happen. Just dont want to see Melo get an outsized role in the offense.

Dont know what Berman is basing this on, but I hope he's right about star power. Have to give credit to Perry for giving the Knicks the flexibilty to do that



Perry “Gave the knicks flex”? Really? Like a gift? OR Devine intervention? Or Defied Mills? Or The owner told him to keep it all open as he did with Layden before Isiah cashed it all in? I do like this build up of assets and its gong to be interesting if, how and when they use it.

Yes, really. What did Mills do between the time Phil was fired, and Perry was hired? Sign Baker to how much? Sign Hardaway for how much?

Dont believe its a coincidence that the deals got better for NY's cap flexibilty after Perry was hired. You want to praise Mills again, be my guest. I didnt see that discipline pre-Perry.

Relax......
My point is not about MIlls and Baker, its not Perry driving the ship. ITs the directive to accumulate assets.
I’m not defending mills. Records speak for itself. Let’s not even go to the place who did what. Let’s just say “Knicks signed Morris”.....and thats “Knicks got a good return”. Just normal decisions.
Who drove the KP bus? Phil wanted him traded, Dolan nixed it.
Blame Mills for the aftermath, no IM blaming “Knicks”.
I like Perry, but I don’t the directive as much as you do.
PErry does not set the goals of the team. He might execute it better.

Quite calm thanks. Im used to the reflexive defense of Mills by now. Talking about fiscal discipline and practicing it are two different things. Phil talked about it, then went for the quick fix. Signed Noah(a bench player at that point) to a ridiculous deal, still on the books . Mills talked about it, and in that great Knick tradition, also bid against himself.


I've never quite understood the reflex Mills defense syndrome Nalod seems to exhibit. Maybe it's some sort of weird side effect of Phil love?

Anyway, Phil making a million a month to nap while not knowing sheehit about being a franchise Prez and then talking about fiscal discipline is not only different from practicing fiscal discipline, it's also hilarious.

jrodmc @ 3/24/2020 9:27 AM
Knixkik wrote:I'm really only interested in Melo if we move Randle. Not interested in seeing Randle and Melo takes turns playing iso. But Melo off the bench as a bucket getter is reasonable if there's no other iso players.

And Melo gives you Iso(what?) without the spinover!

Nalod @ 3/24/2020 12:11 PM
jrodmc wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:
Nalod wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:
Nalod wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:Probably all.but a done deal. Guessing mgmt believes fans will want to turn the clock back a bit and bring Melo back in part for sentimantal reasons. Times being what they are now. I hope we have a team good enough to make Melo not mind coming off the bench. Not too keen on Melo starting. Not sentimental for ISO ball.
I feel the same way. I enjoyed Melo's time in NY but it has passed. I don't see him taking on a Vince Carter type role but I could be wrong. He also may not be ready to retire after next year. I thought it was interesting that Berman thinks Rose will bring in some star power to MSG.

We saw Melo lead the team in assists for a season. We talk about "Olympic Melo" Id be happy with that Melo who was looking to get everyone involved. It could happen. Just dont want to see Melo get an outsized role in the offense.

Dont know what Berman is basing this on, but I hope he's right about star power. Have to give credit to Perry for giving the Knicks the flexibilty to do that



Perry “Gave the knicks flex”? Really? Like a gift? OR Devine intervention? Or Defied Mills? Or The owner told him to keep it all open as he did with Layden before Isiah cashed it all in? I do like this build up of assets and its gong to be interesting if, how and when they use it.

Yes, really. What did Mills do between the time Phil was fired, and Perry was hired? Sign Baker to how much? Sign Hardaway for how much?

Dont believe its a coincidence that the deals got better for NY's cap flexibilty after Perry was hired. You want to praise Mills again, be my guest. I didnt see that discipline pre-Perry.

Relax......
My point is not about MIlls and Baker, its not Perry driving the ship. ITs the directive to accumulate assets.
I’m not defending mills. Records speak for itself. Let’s not even go to the place who did what. Let’s just say “Knicks signed Morris”.....and thats “Knicks got a good return”. Just normal decisions.
Who drove the KP bus? Phil wanted him traded, Dolan nixed it.
Blame Mills for the aftermath, no IM blaming “Knicks”.
I like Perry, but I don’t the directive as much as you do.
PErry does not set the goals of the team. He might execute it better.

Quite calm thanks. Im used to the reflexive defense of Mills by now. Talking about fiscal discipline and practicing it are two different things. Phil talked about it, then went for the quick fix. Signed Noah(a bench player at that point) to a ridiculous deal, still on the books . Mills talked about it, and in that great Knick tradition, also bid against himself.


I've never quite understood the reflex Mills defense syndrome Nalod seems to exhibit. Maybe it's some sort of weird side effect of Phil love?

Anyway, Phil making a million a month to nap while not knowing sheehit about being a franchise Prez and then talking about fiscal discipline is not only different from practicing fiscal discipline, it's also hilarious.

Its ignorant.
I been defending them for years. BLame Layden for Mcdyess, like he had to power to take on that money. Isiah got blame cuz he took on Marbury when Layden pushed back. Walsh gets blamed for Amare/Melo, etc etc. Phil gets blamed as if the knicks did not suck before he walked in. He deserves blame for not making it bettter, but then we learned he gets canned for wanting to move KP before he broke. MIlls? I blame circumstance not him personally. KP broke. Bad luck.

Let’s start this now. Leon in charge, Knicks suck. He to blame? How long we give him?

Page 1 of 2