Knicks · Toney Douglas or Mike Bibby (page 1)

Ok so there is a decent 5-15 minutes needed to be handed out to one of the two when BD goes out. Lately we have dealt with Iman or JR just running the point and thats also a option we could just keep doing so we do not have to play neither of TD or Bibby. Bibby is slow as molasses on defense while TD is just dumb founded on the court. Obviously TD has the most potential but has not improved since his sophomore year. TD has had the last couple games to try to win the 2nd string job but only delivered in one game while Bibby just got his shot last night and was very below average...What do we do these are valuable minutes?

TD..at least he plays D

Picking the lesser of two evils I go with TD. Unfortunately, TD makes too many mistakes and Woody doesn't play those who make mistakes.

I agree its pick your poison. But if he can play defense like he guarded Chris Duhon and Jameer Nelson he could be valuable. I wish he just had common sense on the court...

TD. by default because bibby is like dead person. TD lives

Shumpert

They both suck, we need to sign the best NBDL PG to 10 day contract.

Tell the ghost of mike bibby to retire. TD can lock in on D and bang a 3.

Killa4luv wrote:Tell the ghost of mike bibby to retire. TD can lock in on D and bang a 3.

Baron is playing o heart alone and has been for weeks. No way to go forward with Bibby he has no chance of staying in front of anyone. I don't even know this guy wearing 23 he looks nothing like DWTDD

2 very inconsistent shooters who don't penetrate well or play defense. At least Bibby knows his role and doesn't try to overdo it. Every dribble one of them take is a waste of time. Douglas gets cut off so easily and is always forced to pick up his dribble. Bibby can't go anywhere but at least he can make an entry pass and knows to get the ball out of his hands. Douglas occasionally plays some nice d but he gets burned, caught napping, or causes breakdowns by gambling for every steal. Take your pick...

Toney Douglas is more athletic and plays harder. Bibby makes better decisions. Truth is, I really hate them both, but I'd lean to Bibby just because I don't have this overwelming sense of doom every time he approaches the scorer's table.

We need Lin to get himself some herbal miracle cure.

Bibby, I saw enough of TD.

It's a tough choice. Bibby literally does nothing- he doesn't score, defend or hand out assists, BUT he doesn't really turn the ball over or lose us leads- he literally has no impact on the game positive or negaitive.

TD can defend, and there's always the chance that he might score or get an assist. BUT he turns the ball over in the most ridiculous ways and seems to destroy any lead we have.

Elite wrote:Shumpert

Basically

Perhaps they could be merged into one good player? Tonibby?

Bibby Knows he sucks..tD thinks he is still good...I'll take Bibby..at least he doesn't hurt us on Offense.

If you could merge all of Toney's strengths and all of Mike Bibby's, you might have a solid role player.

HugeKnick4 wrote:TD..at least he plays D

Bibby, at least he won't dribble all the way to the base line, run around in circles then chuck up a bad shot. At least Bibby will make sure the ball moves and will likely get it to the right man. Douglas must have premature Alzheimer or something to have regressed to badly.

Bonn1997 wrote:If you could merge all of Toney's strengths and all of Mike Bibby's, you might have a solid role player.

Nah the merge would still suck lol. A Young Bibby maybe.

FoeDiddy wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:If you could merge all of Toney's strengths and all of Mike Bibby's, you might have a solid role player.

Nah the merge would still suck lol. A Young Bibby maybe.

Well you'd at least have a solid NBDL role player!

Bonn1997 wrote:

FoeDiddy wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:If you could merge all of Toney's strengths and all of Mike Bibby's, you might have a solid role player.

Nah the merge would still suck lol. A Young Bibby maybe.

Well you'd at least have a solid NBDL role player!

A Solid WNBA player..Juwanna Man