holfresh wrote:StarksEwing1 wrote:holfresh wrote:StarksEwing1 wrote:Look I dont hate melo. I think he is a great scorer. But people act like he an elite player who has had playoff success. For the most part he has been a first round exit every year. I dont wnat to trade him but if the right deal came along that gave us a very good young player and draft picks then i would do it in a heartbeat
Crazy first round exit comments without examining who they played and what the circumstances were..How on earth were Melo to beat Bron and Wade with our entire team decimated last year..and Boston the year before???...How??...Dude is a top five player...
Oh Lord i should have known if i say anything even remotely critical about melo holfresh will go nuts lol. Look I never said to trade him but if we get offered a good package then you have to do it
If you should say something critical??...How about making sense then...U should say, If I say something that don't make sense Holfresh will be all over me...I'll trade him for the right package as well..U aren't breaking any ground here..But Blake Griffin and Jordan for Melo and Chandler is crazy...
Relax First of all I never said i like that trade proposal. also I said that i DIDNT want to trade Melo BUT if we are blown away by a great offer then i would consider it.
StarksEwing1 wrote:holfresh wrote:StarksEwing1 wrote:holfresh wrote:StarksEwing1 wrote:Look I dont hate melo. I think he is a great scorer. But people act like he an elite player who has had playoff success. For the most part he has been a first round exit every year. I dont wnat to trade him but if the right deal came along that gave us a very good young player and draft picks then i would do it in a heartbeat
Crazy first round exit comments without examining who they played and what the circumstances were..How on earth were Melo to beat Bron and Wade with our entire team decimated last year..and Boston the year before???...How??...Dude is a top five player...
Oh Lord i should have known if i say anything even remotely critical about melo holfresh will go nuts lol. Look I never said to trade him but if we get offered a good package then you have to do it
If you should say something critical??...How about making sense then...U should say, If I say something that don't make sense Holfresh will be all over me...I'll trade him for the right package as well..U aren't breaking any ground here..But Blake Griffin and Jordan for Melo and Chandler is crazy...
Relax First of all I never said i like that trade proposal. also I said that i DIDNT want to trade Melo BUT if we are blown away by a great offer then i would consider it.
I'm very relaxed..U aren't saying anything that 100% of the participants of this forum wouldn't consider or do..
holfresh wrote:StarksEwing1 wrote:holfresh wrote:StarksEwing1 wrote:holfresh wrote:StarksEwing1 wrote:Look I dont hate melo. I think he is a great scorer. But people act like he an elite player who has had playoff success. For the most part he has been a first round exit every year. I dont wnat to trade him but if the right deal came along that gave us a very good young player and draft picks then i would do it in a heartbeat
Crazy first round exit comments without examining who they played and what the circumstances were..How on earth were Melo to beat Bron and Wade with our entire team decimated last year..and Boston the year before???...How??...Dude is a top five player...
Oh Lord i should have known if i say anything even remotely critical about melo holfresh will go nuts lol. Look I never said to trade him but if we get offered a good package then you have to do it
If you should say something critical??...How about making sense then...U should say, If I say something that don't make sense Holfresh will be all over me...I'll trade him for the right package as well..U aren't breaking any ground here..But Blake Griffin and Jordan for Melo and Chandler is crazy...
Relax First of all I never said i like that trade proposal. also I said that i DIDNT want to trade Melo BUT if we are blown away by a great offer then i would consider it.
I'm very relaxed..U aren't saying anything that 100% of the participants of this forum wouldn't consider or do..
Holfresh you realize that i wasnt trying to be special. I wasnt trying to outsmart any fans. I was just stating my opinion
I don't know Irish, u always get me going..
holfresh wrote:I don't know Irish, u always get me going..
Im Italian but anyway like i said before i dont wnat to trade the guy at least until ater the season and we see how we do
StarksEwing1 wrote:holfresh wrote:I don't know Irish, u always get me going..
Im Italian but anyway like i said before i dont wnat to trade the guy at least until ater the season and we see how we do
He can't be traded any sooner than that anyway
StarksEwing1 wrote:holfresh wrote:I don't know Irish, u always get me going..
Im Italian but anyway like i said before i dont wnat to trade the guy at least until ater the season and we see how we do
Anything u say Irish, 
AnubisADL wrote:This has little to no chance of happening. However, if the Knicks wanted to do Melo a solid and rebuild this summer they could send him too the Clippers to play with Chris Paul. Melo and Chandler
for
Jordan, Griffin, Butler
Melo and Chandler reunited with CP3.
We wont even be able to trade him because the Knicks want him to ruin his knee
StarksEwing1 wrote:holfresh wrote:StarksEwing1 wrote:holfresh wrote:StarksEwing1 wrote:Look I dont hate melo. I think he is a great scorer. But people act like he an elite player who has had playoff success. For the most part he has been a first round exit every year. I dont wnat to trade him but if the right deal came along that gave us a very good young player and draft picks then i would do it in a heartbeat
Crazy first round exit comments without examining who they played and what the circumstances were..How on earth were Melo to beat Bron and Wade with our entire team decimated last year..and Boston the year before???...How??...Dude is a top five player...
Oh Lord i should have known if i say anything even remotely critical about melo holfresh will go nuts lol. Look I never said to trade him but if we get offered a good package then you have to do it
If you should say something critical??...How about making sense then...U should say, If I say something that don't make sense Holfresh will be all over me...I'll trade him for the right package as well..U aren't breaking any ground here..But Blake Griffin and Jordan for Melo and Chandler is crazy...
Relax First of all I never said i like that trade proposal. also I said that i DIDNT want to trade Melo BUT if we are blown away by a great offer then i would consider it.
Now there's a thread title! When were the Knicks approached with anything great in a trade offer?
LOL at not willing to trade Griffin for Melo.
holfresh wrote:Bonn1997 wrote:BRIGGS wrote:VCoug wrote:Only if LAC threw in Bledsoe, a 1st, and a 2nd.
I wouldnt trade Griffin for Carmelo--would you?
No way. It's ridiculous.
U guys are nuts...
Change of heart yet???
Griffin has a good post game but mainly thrives off pick and roll. And Paul is arguably the best pick and roll guard in the league. And Blake is possibly the best finisher. I don't think they would break that up.
i think griffin is the most overrated player in the nba. id rather have melo.
You think we can get Nate back for Melo?
nyk4ever wrote:i think griffin is the most overrated player in the nba. id rather have melo.
Not to disrespect your opinion, but I hear this a lot. And the only argument I hear is the "all he can do is dunk" routine and its garbage. Do these people only watch espn highlights?
holfresh wrote:holfresh wrote:Bonn1997 wrote:BRIGGS wrote:VCoug wrote:Only if LAC threw in Bledsoe, a 1st, and a 2nd.
I wouldnt trade Griffin for Carmelo--would you?
No way. It's ridiculous.
U guys are nuts...
Change of heart yet???
I find it hilarious that you asked yourself this question
If we lose this year, with the age of this roster, honestly, you have to consider it.
But the truth is, it has a 0% chance of happening. Melo will be on the Knicks for life, barring him causing a media nightmare that makes Dolan reconsider.
Solace wrote:If we lose this year, with the age of this roster, honestly, you have to consider it.But the truth is, it has a 0% chance of happening. Melo will be on the Knicks for life, barring him causing a media nightmare that makes Dolan reconsider.
We have already seen a media nightmare; bus chasing on camera, anyone? What do we need, a fight with a heckler in the stands? The average seat bearing fan loves the Melo.
holfresh for nastiest I told you so thread bump of the year!
jrodmc wrote:Solace wrote:If we lose this year, with the age of this roster, honestly, you have to consider it.But the truth is, it has a 0% chance of happening. Melo will be on the Knicks for life, barring him causing a media nightmare that makes Dolan reconsider.
We have already seen a media nightmare; bus chasing on camera, anyone? What do we need, a fight with a heckler in the stands? The average seat bearing fan loves the Melo.
holfresh for nastiest I told you so thread bump of the year!
That wasn't a media nightmare. 
holfresh wrote:StarksEwing1 wrote:holfresh wrote:StarksEwing1 wrote:Look I dont hate melo. I think he is a great scorer. But people act like he an elite player who has had playoff success. For the most part he has been a first round exit every year. I dont wnat to trade him but if the right deal came along that gave us a very good young player and draft picks then i would do it in a heartbeat
Crazy first round exit comments without examining who they played and what the circumstances were..How on earth were Melo to beat Bron and Wade with our entire team decimated last year..and Boston the year before???...How??...Dude is a top five player...
Oh Lord i should have known if i say anything even remotely critical about melo holfresh will go nuts lol. Look I never said to trade him but if we get offered a good package then you have to do it
If you should say something critical??...How about making sense then...U should say, If I say something that don't make sense Holfresh will be all over me...I'll trade him for the right package as well..U aren't breaking any ground here..But Blake Griffin and Jordan for Melo and Chandler is crazy...Care to expalin the first round exit comments???
Clippers not getting out of first round means nothing. As a Melo fan you should know its really tough to win those virtually unfair west first round matchups.
