Knicks · Knicks traded for Towns (finally official 10/1) (page 43)

Uptown wrote:Regardless of how any of us feel about Kat and or what happens in the future for this team, that 4th qaurter performance will go down as one of the greatest playoff quarters in the history of this franchise.

His game 3 shots vs DET were massive as well in a critical game we had to win. What’s crazy is how they’ve been overshadowed by so many wild plays that followed them.

DLeethal wrote:

martin wrote:

DLeethal wrote:Mitch and filler for Draymond. Can’t think of a better compliment to KAT defensively.

Herb Jones

I’m with it. Taller Nesmith?

Maybe the slight body type of Mikal with a bit more height and combine it with strength and explosion that OG has and with much better ball handling than both. He is a ball mover like Josh but more willing of a scorer and light years better defender than Hart. Thibs guy. You’d have to give up Mitch, and Mitch is the perfect player for the Pelicans IMHO. It’s a swap that makes too much sense for both teams.

And then I’d move KAT just for funnsies

Panos 9/27/2024 10:34 PM wrote:Nooooo

This was my initial reaction to the KAT trade, and I think I'm back there. I just don't want him on the team. He's a knucklehead. I can't stand seeing him make the same stupid a) defensive fouls, and b) or drives that are either nearly offensive fouls or getting his shot blocked. He looked good early on, particularly because he was making good passes, but he stopped that, and now just bulldozes into multiple defenders. I'm really done with him. I wish we could rewind the clock.

Panos wrote:

Panos 9/27/2024 10:34 PM wrote:Nooooo

This was my initial reaction to the KAT trade, and I think I'm back there. I just don't want him on the team. He's a knucklehead. I can't stand seeing him make the same stupid a) defensive fouls, and b) or drives that are either nearly offensive fouls or getting his shot blocked. He looked good early on, particularly because he was making good passes, but he stopped that, and now just bulldozes into multiple defenders. I'm really done with him. I wish we could rewind the clock.

I couldn’t even comment on this thread the first day. I went from diehard fan to not even looking forward to the season.

Panos wrote:

Panos 9/27/2024 10:34 PM wrote:Nooooo

This was my initial reaction to the KAT trade, and I think I'm back there. I just don't want him on the team. He's a knucklehead. I can't stand seeing him make the same stupid a) defensive fouls, and b) or drives that are either nearly offensive fouls or getting his shot blocked. He looked good early on, particularly because he was making good passes, but he stopped that, and now just bulldozes into multiple defenders. I'm really done with him. I wish we could rewind the clock.

Passing KAT is elite and that's what I want. Thibs will not give it to us tho. ISO KAT is not something I like, but then I don't like ISO Brunson either,unless it's with less than 5 mins left.

I honestly feel like Brunson+KAT can be a #1 offense in the league. A stronger offense can offset the D shortcomings of this pairing. But it's not going to happen under Thibs. Out of Brunson, KAT and Thibs- one of them has to go

ramtour420 wrote:

Panos wrote:

Panos 9/27/2024 10:34 PM wrote:Nooooo

This was my initial reaction to the KAT trade, and I think I'm back there. I just don't want him on the team. He's a knucklehead. I can't stand seeing him make the same stupid a) defensive fouls, and b) or drives that are either nearly offensive fouls or getting his shot blocked. He looked good early on, particularly because he was making good passes, but he stopped that, and now just bulldozes into multiple defenders. I'm really done with him. I wish we could rewind the clock.

Passing KAT is elite and that's what I want. Thibs will not give it to us tho. ISO KAT is not something I like, but then I don't like ISO Brunson either,unless it's with less than 5 mins left.

I honestly feel like Brunson+KAT can be a #1 offense in the league. A stronger offense can offset the D shortcomings of this pairing. But it's not going to happen under Thibs. Out of Brunson, KAT and Thibs- one of them has to go

This is insightful and speaks to the limitations imposed by this offensive scheme - or lack thereof.

What ever happened to passing KAT from the early season? Dude was doing Rucker park no look pass shit on a nightly basis. What happened to the offense of the early season needs to be studied. Is it simply every team put a small on Towns and a roaming big on Hart and that was RIP elite offense?

DLeethal wrote:What ever happened to passing KAT from the early season? Dude was doing Rucker park no look pass shit on a nightly basis. What happened to the offense of the early season needs to be studied. Is it simply every team put a small on Towns and a roaming big on Hart and that was RIP elite offense?

I thought it all changed when he got hurt and then it never came back. However, that may have coincided with how he was being played as well.

ramtour420 wrote:

Panos wrote:

Panos 9/27/2024 10:34 PM wrote:Nooooo

This was my initial reaction to the KAT trade, and I think I'm back there. I just don't want him on the team. He's a knucklehead. I can't stand seeing him make the same stupid a) defensive fouls, and b) or drives that are either nearly offensive fouls or getting his shot blocked. He looked good early on, particularly because he was making good passes, but he stopped that, and now just bulldozes into multiple defenders. I'm really done with him. I wish we could rewind the clock.

Passing KAT is elite and that's what I want. Thibs will not give it to us tho. ISO KAT is not something I like, but then I don't like ISO Brunson either,unless it's with less than 5 mins left.

I honestly feel like Brunson+KAT can be a #1 offense in the league. A stronger offense can offset the D shortcomings of this pairing. But it's not going to happen under Thibs. Out of Brunson, KAT and Thibs- one of them has to go

Think this is fair.
Offense has been built around Brunson. Ie., give him the ball and spread the floor. No back cutting wanted no off ball picks. This comes from coaching staff. They just added KAT to be a secondary ISO player in case Brunson gets doubled and to be a floor spacer. Not exactly what you want to ask of a $60M contract.

The sad thing is that we have the roster for a quick passing offense. Quick decisions with 3 second hold times. Drive , kick and rotate the ball to any of our guys and I feel they can do something positive. Well maybe except for Hart.

HofstraBBall wrote:

ramtour420 wrote:

Panos wrote:

Panos 9/27/2024 10:34 PM wrote:Nooooo

This was my initial reaction to the KAT trade, and I think I'm back there. I just don't want him on the team. He's a knucklehead. I can't stand seeing him make the same stupid a) defensive fouls, and b) or drives that are either nearly offensive fouls or getting his shot blocked. He looked good early on, particularly because he was making good passes, but he stopped that, and now just bulldozes into multiple defenders. I'm really done with him. I wish we could rewind the clock.

Passing KAT is elite and that's what I want. Thibs will not give it to us tho. ISO KAT is not something I like, but then I don't like ISO Brunson either,unless it's with less than 5 mins left.

I honestly feel like Brunson+KAT can be a #1 offense in the league. A stronger offense can offset the D shortcomings of this pairing. But it's not going to happen under Thibs. Out of Brunson, KAT and Thibs- one of them has to go

Think this is fair.
Offense has been built around Brunson. Ie., give him the ball and spread the floor. No back cutting wanted no off ball picks. This comes from coaching staff. They just added KAT to be a secondary ISO player in case Brunson gets doubled and to be a floor spacer. Not exactly what you want to ask of a $60M contract.

The sad thing is that we have the roster for a quick passing offense. Quick decisions with 3 second hold times. Drive , kick and rotate the ball to any of our guys and I feel they can do something positive. Well maybe except for Hart.

Except for OG, you mean. Who will bobble the ball and kick it out of bounds. Hart can pass.

Awful season. Team made it to ECF's first time in 25 years.
Minutes police wore bodycams this year and was found innocent.

Carlisle might be a better coach than Thibs.

Nalod wrote:Awful season. Team made it to ECF's first time in 25 years.
Minutes police wore bodycams this year and was found innocent.

Carlisle might be a better coach than Thibs.

Could be. He was also the coach who didn't do very much with young Brunson, Doncic, KP lineup.

martin wrote:

Nalod wrote:Awful season. Team made it to ECF's first time in 25 years.
Minutes police wore bodycams this year and was found innocent.

Carlisle might be a better coach than Thibs.

Could be. He was also the coach who didn't do very much with young Brunson, Doncic, KP lineup.

So one can surmise its not plug and play?
Rick had a good run with Detroit, then came to Dallas were he won a chip.
So players matter. Chemistry matters. Injuries matter.
What guarantee is Spo, Kidd or Rick himself would do better? None.
"Can't do worse"? Yes they could.
Knicks got here on talent.

Panos wrote:

HofstraBBall wrote:

ramtour420 wrote:

Panos wrote:

Panos 9/27/2024 10:34 PM wrote:Nooooo

This was my initial reaction to the KAT trade, and I think I'm back there. I just don't want him on the team. He's a knucklehead. I can't stand seeing him make the same stupid a) defensive fouls, and b) or drives that are either nearly offensive fouls or getting his shot blocked. He looked good early on, particularly because he was making good passes, but he stopped that, and now just bulldozes into multiple defenders. I'm really done with him. I wish we could rewind the clock.

Passing KAT is elite and that's what I want. Thibs will not give it to us tho. ISO KAT is not something I like, but then I don't like ISO Brunson either,unless it's with less than 5 mins left.

I honestly feel like Brunson+KAT can be a #1 offense in the league. A stronger offense can offset the D shortcomings of this pairing. But it's not going to happen under Thibs. Out of Brunson, KAT and Thibs- one of them has to go

Think this is fair.
Offense has been built around Brunson. Ie., give him the ball and spread the floor. No back cutting wanted no off ball picks. This comes from coaching staff. They just added KAT to be a secondary ISO player in case Brunson gets doubled and to be a floor spacer. Not exactly what you want to ask of a $60M contract.

The sad thing is that we have the roster for a quick passing offense. Quick decisions with 3 second hold times. Drive , kick and rotate the ball to any of our guys and I feel they can do something positive. Well maybe except for Hart.

Except for OG, you mean. Who will bobble the ball and kick it out of bounds. Hart can pass.

OG can hit an open three. Hart? Maybe sometimes.
But yeah, he can be frustrating as well.

Panos wrote:

Panos 9/27/2024 10:34 PM wrote:Nooooo

This was my initial reaction to the KAT trade, and I think I'm back there. I just don't want him on the team. He's a knucklehead. I can't stand seeing him make the same stupid a) defensive fouls, and b) or drives that are either nearly offensive fouls or getting his shot blocked. He looked good early on, particularly because he was making good passes, but he stopped that, and now just bulldozes into multiple defenders. I'm really done with him. I wish we could rewind the clock.

I've had many of the same reactions to Kat's bad decisions and sloppiness.

But dude is putting up #s - highly effecient #s and his D (outside of awful drop coverage) has been solid in playoffs (he can guard).

Averaging 26/12 on 52/46/84 % shooting %s.

He is averaging almost as many rebounds (12) as entire Pacers frontline combined Siakim (5), Turner (4), Nesmith (5) combined.