Knicks · So when is Hart getting surgery? (page 1)

Philc1 @ 11/1/2025 9:26 AM
Hopefully sooner rather than later so we can get him back for the playoffs. He was never a good shooter to begin with but this is ridiculous he’s 50% on free throws.
ToddTT @ 11/1/2025 11:40 AM
He should have gotten it weeks ago.
ToddTT @ 11/1/2025 12:02 PM
Or maybe the doctors are stumped.
Nalod @ 11/1/2025 12:20 PM
He had it over the summer. It takes time to regain the sensation. I guess PHilC has his medical records or in in converstaion with Josh but from what is said Hart thinks its going to take time. If redoing the procedure it will no doubt be a big setback.
Medicine is not a defined process and why its called "practicing medicine". sometimes things work, sometimes they don't.
No guarantee another surgery yields a better result and there could be a chance it worsens?

NBA players will tell us what we want to hear but we just never know how, when or if nerve ending regain its full capacity.
What is the right thing for him to do? Maybe nobody knows and its prudent to wait? There are long term ramifications to his career that we are not considering. Fans want to win now!

ramtour420 @ 11/1/2025 1:00 PM
I am sure he is taking neuroleptics to speed up nerve growth/recovery. He has to, given how he is a millionaire and has access to the best medical treatment money can buy. Btw, Lions Mane mushrooms are pretty amazing for this purpose
Philc1 @ 11/1/2025 5:09 PM
Nalod wrote:He had it over the summer. It takes time to regain the sensation. I guess PHilC has his medical records or in in converstaion with Josh but from what is said Hart thinks its going to take time. If redoing the procedure it will no doubt be a big setback.
Medicine is not a defined process and why its called "practicing medicine". sometimes things work, sometimes they don't.
No guarantee another surgery yields a better result and there could be a chance it worsens?

NBA players will tell us what we want to hear but we just never know how, when or if nerve ending regain its full capacity.
What is the right thing for him to do? Maybe nobody knows and its prudent to wait? There are long term ramifications to his career that we are not considering. Fans want to win now!

Do I need medical records to check on Josh Hart shooting 20%? Elf laughs at that

Philc1 @ 11/1/2025 5:10 PM
ToddTT wrote:He should have gotten it weeks ago.

He is dragging this out and will end up getting surgery in January. Just in time for him to miss rest of the season including playoffs. Alec Burks please.

Nalod @ 11/1/2025 6:58 PM
Philc1 wrote:
Nalod wrote:He had it over the summer. It takes time to regain the sensation. I guess PHilC has his medical records or in in converstaion with Josh but from what is said Hart thinks its going to take time. If redoing the procedure it will no doubt be a big setback.
Medicine is not a defined process and why its called "practicing medicine". sometimes things work, sometimes they don't.
No guarantee another surgery yields a better result and there could be a chance it worsens?

NBA players will tell us what we want to hear but we just never know how, when or if nerve ending regain its full capacity.
What is the right thing for him to do? Maybe nobody knows and its prudent to wait? There are long term ramifications to his career that we are not considering. Fans want to win now!

Do I need medical records to check on Josh Hart shooting 20%? Elf laughs at that

he has taken all of 19 shots in 89 minutes. Nobody says he is not huring. He admits it. But who thinks to offer advice with assumptive ignorince? Elf laughs at you, not with you.

HofstraBBall @ 11/2/2025 7:08 AM
He is passing on surgery and focusing on new treatments involving lots of breast milk.
BigDaddyG @ 11/2/2025 9:01 AM
HofstraBBall wrote:He is passing on surgery and focusing on new treatments involving lots of breast milk.

Nalod @ 11/3/2025 11:10 PM
Philc1 wrote:
Nalod wrote:He had it over the summer. It takes time to regain the sensation. I guess PHilC has his medical records or in in converstaion with Josh but from what is said Hart thinks its going to take time. If redoing the procedure it will no doubt be a big setback.
Medicine is not a defined process and why its called "practicing medicine". sometimes things work, sometimes they don't.
No guarantee another surgery yields a better result and there could be a chance it worsens?

NBA players will tell us what we want to hear but we just never know how, when or if nerve ending regain its full capacity.
What is the right thing for him to do? Maybe nobody knows and its prudent to wait? There are long term ramifications to his career that we are not considering. Fans want to win now!

Do I need medical records to check on Josh Hart shooting 20%? Elf laughs at that

Elf wants to know if you saw the last two games.

Nalod @ 11/6/2025 8:11 AM
Philc1 wrote:
Nalod wrote:He had it over the summer. It takes time to regain the sensation. I guess PHilC has his medical records or in in converstaion with Josh but from what is said Hart thinks its going to take time. If redoing the procedure it will no doubt be a big setback.
Medicine is not a defined process and why its called "practicing medicine". sometimes things work, sometimes they don't.
No guarantee another surgery yields a better result and there could be a chance it worsens?

NBA players will tell us what we want to hear but we just never know how, when or if nerve ending regain its full capacity.
What is the right thing for him to do? Maybe nobody knows and its prudent to wait? There are long term ramifications to his career that we are not considering. Fans want to win now!

Do I need medical records to check on Josh Hart shooting 20%? Elf laughs at that

You don't need his medical records. You need to think.
BTW, nothing wrong with sticking your neck out but if you wrong be a man about it.
Nobody expected him to be a good shooter as he has not his career, but he trending better.

martin @ 11/6/2025 8:22 AM
Never. The answer is Never
VDesai @ 11/6/2025 3:59 PM
Crazy how much he turned it around and how quickly. I was worried he had the yips. He actually doesn't even seem 100 pct yet, bc he is still not his best in transition and finishing (where he ranks among the best in the game IMO). The shot coming around has been awesome. That is probably more about his back then his hand He has been streaky since he has been here, but the confidence to take the is the biggest thing.
Page 1 of 1